Predictions are a blast. I love watching the ‘experts’ try and figure out who will be there at the end of the season, and why. Remember last year? It seemed like everyone was on the Seattle bandwagon, picking them to go to the Super Bowl. I got so excited last season because the ‘experts’ were picking my team. But let’s get real: we knew the ‘Hawks were going to drop too many passes, the defense was young, and they had not established that killer instinct that so many championship teams have.
In short, no one was really paying attention to the facts.
But it’s a new season, and we can learn, can’t we? Billy Simmons points out this interesting factoid about playoff teams:
Every season, six playoff teams make it back, six playoff teams drop out, and six other teams fill those spots. This is how it works. This is how it always works.
I haven’t verified this, but it sounds right. I remember he wrote a similiar piece last season.
I’ve watched about as much pre-season football as I could find on my DISH Network satellite. It’s not a huge sampling, and it is only pre-season, but I did learn some things. Here’s my picks:
AFC
Division Winners: Patriots, Ravens, Colts, Chiefs.
Wild Cards: Chargers, Jets
NFC
Division Winners: Eagles, Vikings, Panthers, Seahawks
Wild Cards: Falcons, Rams
Super Bowl: Colts vs. Panthers, and Colts win. (Yes, I think Peyton Manning finally solves the Patriots this season).
Why these teams? I think the one thing that the ‘experts’ constantly overlook is the youth at the quarterback position. You’ve got too many people saying that QB’s with little experience (like Buffalo’s J.P. Losman and Chicago’s Kyle Orten) are going to win for their teams. Balony. It never happens that way. Until Ben Roethlisberger last year, Dan Marino was the last guy to walk into the NFL and win immediately. The quarterback position is too important in this league for teams with sub-par QB’s to even have a remote chance of getting into the post season.
Picking these teams is more a process of elimination than it is choosing the good teams. Go down the list of teams you know aren’t going to be in the playoff hunt at season’s end: 49ers, Bears, Lions, Dolphins, Titans, Raiders, Browns, and Bills. For one reason or another (weak QB, poor defense, overall lack of team depth/talent) these teams don’t have the whole package to compete for a playoff spot. These teams are out of the playoff hunt before the season starts, they just don’t know it yet.
The team that probably will surprise someone for not being on the post-season list: Steelers.
Hey, I’m a huge fan of Ben Roethlisberger, but let’s face it: Pittsburgh masked him last year. They protected him. They put him in safe situations, gave him a punishing running attack, and a great defense, and asked him to not make mistakes. But both runningbacks are hurt to start the season, and the defense has lost a couple players (Plaxico is gone as well). If you lose a Randy Moss, that’s addition by subtraction. But when you lose a Plaxico Burress and don’t really replace him, that’s not addition. That’s just plain subtraction.
There will be a drop-off this season. The defense will be good, but not dominating. The running game will suffer. Big Ben will make more mistakes as defenses gameplan for him. They won’t make the playoffs. Bettis will finally retire, a Hall of Famer. And then they’ll rebuild the team around Big Ben, and in a season or two all will be well.
Detroit and Arizona are the two enigmas this season.
Detroit has talent, so what’s the problem? Is it really Joey Harrington? I find that hard to believe, because he’s a smart kid. Is it the defense? Is it the fact that every time this team drafts a great WR, he breaks bones and blows a season rehabbing? I’ve never been sold on Marriucci as a playoff calibur coach. He seems like a good guy for getting a team slightly above .500, but he just doesn’t come across to me as a coach with the mindset for the playoffs, like Bill Belichick.
And Arizona… What do we do there? They’re another team with great WR talent, a young RB, and a very talented and well-coached defense. But this is still Arizona, a team that sells more tickets for fans of the opposing team than they do for their own team. I know some ‘experts’ are picking them to win the NFC West, and they could – if the Seahawks and Rams collapse. But I don’t think that happens. They could go 9-7 and I think they still miss the playoffs.
Other thoughts:
Dallas: I can’t believe anyone thinks that Parcells, Bledsoe, and Terry Glenn are going to get this team to the promise land. Yes, the new-look defense will cause havoc. Yes, Julius Jones is a truck and will run over a lot of defenders. But ultimately, as Ron Jaworsky likes to say on NFL Edge Matchup: “Points come out of the Passing Game.” And Bledsoe just doesn’t have it anymore. He looked bad in the pre-season. The pre-season!
Ravens: Boller will be yanked before season’s end, and Wright will lead this team into the playoffs. Mark it down.
Packers: Sorry Packer fans, but you’re staring squarely at a sub .500 season. Your O-line is in shambles, your defense leaks like a sieve. Farve may wish he had retired after this season…
Broncos: Can we put an end to the Jake Plummer experiment already? Let’s face facts: this guy doesn’t possess the accuracy, attention-to-detail, or decision-making-ability of an NFL quarterback. For every flash of brilliance, he makes two boneheaded plays. I love ‘Jake the Snake’ (as a Pac-10 fan you almost have to) but he’s never going to be a Pro Bowl calibur quarterback, let alone John Elway. Plus, this team is starting Cleveland’s D-Line from last season. Cleveland people. Shannahan better find himself a QB in the offseason, and draft some defense in the third round, instead of taking chances on no-talents like Marice Clarett.
Miami & San Fransisco: It’s going to be a looooooong season. I feel for these teams.
Finally, we have these words of wisdom from Billy Simmons:
Because that’s the thing about sleepers: Nobody should be able to predict them. Last year, the Chargers came out of nowhere. The year before, Carolina. In 2001, New England and Chicago. When you hear people throwing the word “sleeper” around for teams like Arizona and Cincy, those are NOT real sleepers. You need to choose someone from this putrid group: Redskins, Giants, Bears, Bucs, Niners, Raiders, Titans, Browns, Bills and Dolphins. I’m telling you, one of those nine teams will make the 2005 playoffs, and everyone is going to say, “Oh my God, how did that happen????”
I’m not picking any of those teams. Yeah, I know – Simmons is right. Every season some team that everyone has written off from the beginning gets their act together and makes a run at the playoffs. But what I really want to know is: what are the common denominators between those teams? What central aspect do those teams share? There has to be some way to detect who those sleepers are.
If I had to pick one team from that group, I’d pick the Giants, because I think Eli Manning will be better (he is a Manning, after all) and I think Tom Coughlin is a good coach who can get the rest of the team to play up to their potential. They have players like Jeremy Shockey, and Tiki Barber, and those types of players can get you some wins. But overall I think the NFC is stronger this season, and it’s just going to be more difficult to get into the playoffs with teams like the Falcons, Vikings, and Panthers on the rise. There’s only six slots avialable…
And I can’t wait.